Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content

Laura's "Rules"

…because until they make better ones, looks like it's up to us.

Laura's "Rules"

Main menu

  • Home
  • Environmental Health & Safety
  • Parenting
  • Recipes & DIY
  • Reflections
  • New? (Posts by Topic)
  • About
  • Media

Tag Archives: Bruce Lourie

The Trouble with Toxics: What Dateline Missed and Why

Posted on March 29, 2013 by Laura MacCleery
7
English: zombie

Small Zombies in the Winter of Our Discontent (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

NBC’s Dateline just this week ran a well-executed two-part series on toxic chemicals that included body burden testing of one of the producers, Andrea Canning, and her three young children. Knowing what I do, it gave me chills to watch Canning intentionally try to raise her chemical levels by doing normal things like eating canned foods and heating plastic in the microwave!

The segments (here and here) include interviews with a scientist and researcher on endocrine disruptors (chemicals that mimic hormones in the body and have been linked to cancer, anxiety and attention deficit, among other health issues), as well as the required skeptic on the risks of toxics and company disclaimers.

The most interesting part of the piece, however, was when Canning, working with Environment Canada‘s Bruce Lourie and Rick Smith, proved that she could both raise and lower the levels of Bisphenol-A (BPA), pthalates and triclosan in her urine over a 24-hour period. This is critical: as I mentioned in an earlier post — Three Days to a Brand-New BPA-Free You — repeated studies, as well as Lourie’s and Smith’s excellent and engaging book, show that BPA and other chemicals can be reduced in a matter of days by being careful about exposures.

Because people tend to get immediately overwhelmed when their attention is raised about the risks from chemicals, it’s important to show that small changes can make a big difference. On the show, Canning switches from canned food to fresh, changes her makeup and personal care products, and stops microwaving in plastic, which are all good changes to make.

She also vows at the close of the series that she will change some of the items her children are exposed to — moved in part by the test results that show BPA and pthalates in all three kids and very high levels of triclosan in two of her children — her two-year-old had levels 100 times the national average!

When the Mcgill skeptic tells her that having this stuff at testable levels in her kids is likely safe, she tries to keep a straight face. As a parent, though, I can tell she’s not buying it, as she makes clear at the end. The truth is, where parents draw the line on risks is often very different than where regulators do, influenced as the government is by industry.

Parents know that this is a moral question — not just an administrative one — and that if a risk can be eliminated by a simple change, they would prefer to err on the side of caution while scientists sort out the issues. No parent wants to be part a grand experiment involving their child, on their watch. Yet given the knowns and unknowns on chemicals, and the sorry state of regulation, that’s essentially what we’ve got going on.

Unfortunately, although Canning is evidently convinced — and stunned a bit by the testing results, Dateline doesn’t do a great job of unpacking the issues generally, potentially leaving consumers confused or even a bit misinformed, as I’ll get to below.

While Dateline cites the Food and Drug Administration’s reassurances on BPA, they fail to explain the FDA’s view that BPA does not get (much) into food from its packaging, not that BPA is necessarily safe to consume. And although Dateline also cites the food industry’s standard line — that BPA is a necessary in can linings to keep the food supply safe — they didn’t mention what my basic Web investigation on the lining of tomato cans turned up, which is that the food preservation BPA provides is a matter of months on a can label, as well as mere pennies per can of cost savings for industry. They also failed to point out that (some, not all) cans and jar lids labeled BPA-free may be lined instead with vinyl, a known carcinogen.

More pointedly, the science on endocrine disruptors is not nearly as inconclusive as the Dateline interview with Mister Mcgill or the Food and Drug Administration would have us believe, as thoroughly demonstrated by the comprehensive summary of the hundreds of relevant studies by the World Health Organization (WHO) published just last month. This release updated a 2002 review which concluded a lack of exposure data meant that little could be conclusively said at that time about endocrine disruptors’ (or “EDCs”) impacts on human health. In contrast, the WHO’s most recent report notes the breadth of studies published in the intervening last decade, which provide:

emerging evidence for adverse reproductive outcomes (infertility, cancers, malformations) from exposure to EDCs, and there is also mounting evidence for effects of these chemicals on thyroid function, brain function, obesity and metabolism, and insulin and glucose homeostasis. [p. 9]

And while I’m being picky, I’ll also complain about the fact that — having worked with TV folks before on occasion, who always like things to be (overly) simple — I know that they picked the low-hanging fruit in terms of public messages and “to do’s.” Unfortunately, in so doing, they ignored a major complicating factor for consumers that Smith and Lourie were no doubt well aware of — the substitution problem. 

Although it would be small step forward if more people understood the pyramid of plastics and avoided plastic items marked with a “7” (or 3 (polyvinyl chloride, PVC) or 6 (polystyrene), for that matter), as we know now, many “BPA-free” plastic items are likely made with Bisphenol-S, Bisphenol-B or some other plastic that may have properties as bad or worse than BPA. I know, depressing, right?

This all points us in a more radical direction. While most people were likely nodding along with Canner as she dutifully checked her sippy cups for the number 7, and her shampoo for “fragrance” or “parfum,” I was screaming at the screen to dump plastic sippies altogether, as well as the Triclosan-laden hand soap, diet soda and canned foods — oh, and the scores of plastic toys in her living room, the electronics and living room sofa filled with flame retardants, the non-organic, industrially farmed foods, the plastic baggies and deli wrap made of PVC, the BPA bowl in the food processor and coffee maker using re-heated plastics, the dish cleaners and laundry detergents with phosphates, the skin lotions with parabens, the take-out food boxes lined in “teflon” PFOAs…

Ok, maybe I can see why Dateline thought it would be too much for viewers. The truth is, we’re swimming in petrochemicals and other nasty substances, and it’s a long, slow, painful and damned expensive journey for consumers to try to tackle any of it. That’s why Florence Williams complained in the New York Times a little while back about how her own body burden test adventures had her eating “like a Mennonite.”

At the time, I thought Williams was being a bit too dismissive of what consumers could do to change things. Maybe it’s our own Mennonite past, back two generations, but we have managed at our house to slowly wean ourselves off almost all packaged foods and have replaced most of the plastics in the kitchen with wood or glass (admittedly at considerable expense). Consumers are more powerful than they think, and companies are springing up every day to cater to this new “greener” customer. So I think its critical that we all do what we can, as we can financially (and mentally!) afford to consider the changes we’d like to make and that we’d like to encourage in the world.

At the same time, wow — it’s a lot of changes, and pricey ones. The problem with talking about toxics is that, like tiny but threatening zombies, these chemicals are hidden everywhere in modern life, waiting to be awakened in your mind and to stagger across your living room, likely at 3 a.m., as your consciousness expands and your credit card takes a beating.

Making matters even worse, someone keenly attuned to these issues will keep feeling duped as they keep learning more, meaning that the emotional cycle of being upset and purging some risk is more-or-less a constant state of being for the anti-toxics avenger. (My latest: Did you know they are now gassing some brands of almonds with a chemical from the antifreeze family? I didn’t until last week. Ick.)

This dynamic poses a challenge for advocates as well, of course. The ubiquity of chemicals — and the banality of their place in everyday, normal products — means that people trying to raise these issues are constantly shuttling between saying we can do something concrete today to save our own skins and saying that we need the government to intervene, because only the government could control all of the risks on our behalf. Both are, of course, perfectly true, despite the obvious tension.

We want consumers to act, as they should, to drive demand for better products. But ironically, to make this action discrete, palatable and not instantly overwhelming, we are often stuck presenting only partial, even dumbed-down information — in Dateline’s case, to the point of false reassurance.

The sad truth is that you can chuck all the “parfumed” products you like, and still end up with yucky parabens and other unhealthy ingredients in your products. It’s not easy being green. At all.

Yet presenting it all at once does run the risk of seeming either paranoid or crazy or both, as I know from hard personal experience. So, OK, Dateline, I get you and your Catch-22. Thanks at least for trying. Next time, please at least mention the loose BPA all over cash register receipts that is likely the largest source of exposure, would ‘ya?

***

Related posts:

  • 10 Free (or Nearly Free) Ways to Reduce Your Family’s Exposure to Toxic Chemicals
  • 5 Myths About Toxics and What to Do About the Truth
  • We’ve Been Slimed — and It’s Not Necessarily Pink
  • My Troubles with Teflon
  • Waiting for Supermom: The FDA’s Failure on BPA
  • My Greener, Healthier Baby and Toddler Supply Guide
  • Want to Reduce Toxic Exposure? Three Useful Principles for Picking Your Battles
  • Rachel Carson’s Unfinished Work: Passing the Safe Chemicals Act
  • Three Days to a Brand-New BPA Free You
  • Burning Questions: An FAQ on Flame Retardants in Furniture
  • How it Ought to Be, One Dollar at a Time
  • Good Parenting for the Chemical Industry

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)

Like this:

Like Loading...
Posted in Environmental Health & Safety | Tagged Andrea Canning, babies, baby, Bisphenol-A, bottles, BPA, Bruce Lourie, cancer, cause, chemicals, Child, children, Dateline, eco-, Endocrine disruptor, Environment Canada, environmental health, Family, FDA, Flame retardant, florence williams, food, Food and Drug Administration, furniture, green, health, healthy, Home, infancy, infants, links, mommy blog, mother, NBC, organic, Parent, parenting, parents, PBDEs, PFOA, precautionary, Rick Smith, sippy cups, Slow Death by Rubber Duck: The Secret Danger of Everyday Things, teflon, toddler, Toxic, toxic chemicals, toxics, uncertainty, United States, WHO, World Health Organization | 7 Replies

Laura & Maya

About this blog

I'm a mom, consumer advocate and self-proclaimed nerd for news on health, safety, green living, food and politics. What happens when a public interest lawyer finally has her own child to think about? Follow me, and find out.

Top Posts & Pages

  • Losing My Beans Over BPA
  • Yummy Veggies for Toddlers 10 Easy Ways
  • Burning Questions: An FAQ on Flame Retardants in Furniture
  • Everything But the Kitchen Sink: 5 Simple Steps to Greener Food Storage and Prep
  • Sofa Saga, Part 4: Some Success! Two Great Sources for Greener Sofas
  • Ouch, Couch! A Sad Sofa Saga... Part 2
  • Media
  • Seeing Red: My Fruitless Search for a Chemical-Free Jar of Tomato Sauce
  • More Misadventures with Flame Retardants: So.Much.Fun.
  • Parenting Through the Fog: 8 of My Personal "Truths"

Recent posts

  • Sowing the Seeds of Change in Chicago: The New “Gardeneers”
  • A Facebook for Federal Bureaucrats, or What Real Government Transparency Might Look Like
  • A Walk in the Woods and a Poem
  • Welcome to the Plutocracy
  • Let the Wild Rumpus Start: 100+ Dazzling Literary Adventures for Young Children
  • Dump Dora, and 7 More Tips to Help You Enjoy Reading to Your Young Child
  • Foxy: An Easy Tutorial for a Needle Felted Fox
  • Parenting Through the Fog: 8 of My Personal “Truths”
  • Toxic Hot Seat on HBO tonight!
  • What I Told EPA About the Climate Crisis and Parenting
  • One-Day Drab-to-Fab Bathroom Makeover with Chalk Paint
  • DIY Furniture Re-Do: Breathing New Life into Furniture with Chalk Paint
  • Ten Easy Tips for Hosting a Greener, Healthier Kid’s Birthday Party
  • Easy DIY Toy: How to Turn an Old Sweater into a Cuddly Snake
  • Making a Spartan Dessert Sing: Chocolate Squares with Lemon Curd
  • Parenting with Neuroscience, and a Laugh
  • California Dreamin’
  • Safer Cosmetics and Personal Care Products: Avoiding the Dreaded “Icky 11”
  • Judgmental Mommy
  • Why Telling Working Moms to Lower their Standards on Parenting Is Actually a Bit Insulting
  • Vacation in a Beautiful Place
  • Easy End-of-Summer Hostess Gift: An Herbal Bouquet
  • Infographic: The Power of Imagination
  • Hot Reads: The Fracking Fight Blows Up, and the Most Compelling Video Clip in Years
  • Big Mama Pig: Oinking Back at Ag Gag Rules
  • One Actual Use for Children’s Artwork
  • Dragonbreath Pickles: Homemade Spicy Cucumber Quick-Pickled Goodness
  • Hot Reads: Cell Phones, Arctic Drilling, Organic but Made in China and More
  • Sheepish: An Easy Needle Felting Tutorial for a Handmade Toy
  • Why Three Kids Feels Like So Much More Than Two
  • Hot Reads: The Plight of the Bumblebee, Fracking and TSCA
  • Children Are a Gift. Except When They Are Not.
  • Everything But the Kitchen Sink: 5 Simple Steps to Greener Food Storage and Prep
  • Hot Reads: CA Takes Back Its Dumb Rule, Chemical Reform Under Contemplation, and More
  • The Resilience of Children, and All of Us
  • Infographic: Have you had this conversation with your child?
  • Is Gardening Actually Green? Some Considerations for the Aspiring Gardener
  • Why “Let Them Eat Crap” Is Not the Answer to the Obesity Crisis
  • Hot Reads: Gagged Children, Huma-liation, Safer School Supplies, and More
  • Parenting as Infographic, Installment #1
  • Mid-Summer Photos: Blueberries, Colorado, and Butterflies
  • Hot Reads: Toxics, Parenting and Other Interesting Stuff
  • For Shame: A Farm Bill that Would Leave Millions of Children Hungry
  • ISO: A Truly Healthy Toddler Snack
  • An Abundance of Needling: A Bunch of Easy Needle Felting Craft Ideas
  • The Hollowing, and an Information Democracy
  • A Conversation that Could Change the World
  • A Shrinking Ocean: Parenting in an Era of Climate Crisis
  • The Un-Toy: A Celebration
  • Asking Safeway: Who Will Mind the Store?

Ask Me Your Questions!

Have a burning question about the environmental health or safety of something for your home or child? Chances are good that I've done some looking into it. Please send me a tweet or put your question in a comment, and I'll follow up!

Topics

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 308 other followers

Follow Me on Pinterest

Tweets

  • Intolerable behavior cannot be tolerated, or we lose all standards: @NYTOpinion: nytimes.com/2021/01/06/opi… 3 months ago
  • via @NYTOpinion This. Thanks, Ezra. nytimes.com/2021/01/07/opi… 3 months ago
  • RT @mollyesque: The amazing thing about "it might have been antifa" is that Trump literally summoned these people to DC, spoke at their eve… 3 months ago
  • RT @chrislhayes: THERE IS STILL BLOOD IN THE CAPITOL AND BEN SASSE IS TALKING ABOUT SHOVELING YOUR NEIGHBOR’S SNOW. 3 months ago
  • RT @ezraklein: The right way for this to end is in the invocation of the 25th amendment. There isn't time or process for impeachment. But T… 3 months ago
Follow @lolamacc

RSS Feed

  • RSS - Posts

Calendar

April 2021
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  
« May    

Categories

  • Environmental Health & Safety
  • Parenting
  • Recipes & DIY
  • Reflections
  • Uncategorized

Archives

  • May 2014
  • April 2014
  • March 2014
  • January 2014
  • November 2013
  • October 2013
  • September 2013
  • August 2013
  • July 2013
  • June 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012
  • November 2012
  • October 2012
  • September 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • June 2012
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012

Search the Site

Blogroll

  • 0 Ecotextiles
  • Adventures in Climate Change
  • Baking Obsession
  • Big Green Purse
  • BioDwell
  • Birth to Thrive
  • Bloodsigns
  • Blue Milk
  • Childhood 101
  • Citizen Green
  • Conscientious Confusion
  • Craftberry Bush
  • Crunchy Domestic Goddess
  • Debra Lynn Dadd
  • Dr. Claudia Miller's blog
  • Edenland
  • Emmy Cooks
  • Femamom
  • Fine Wooden Toys
  • Green Phone Booth
  • Green Your Decor
  • Handmade Charlotte
  • I Never Signed Up for This
  • In Women We Trust
  • Inhabitots
  • Izzy Mom
  • Janet Lansbury
  • Kid Friendly Organic Life
  • Life without Plastic
  • Little Goodall
  • Living the Frugal Life
  • Made by Joel
  • Mindful Momma
  • Mom 101
  • My Plastic-Free Life
  • Nature Moms
  • Nine Naturals
  • Non-Toxic Kids
  • Nutrition Basics
  • One Flew Over the Playpen
  • One Perfect Day
  • Organic Authority
  • Petite Planet
  • PhD in Parenting
  • Puddle jumping in DC
  • Regarding Baby
  • Sharon Astyk
  • Silk Oak
  • Smitten Kitchen
  • Soulemama
  • Squint Mom
  • Strocel
  • Summer Tomato
  • Sweet Greens
  • The Abundant Backyard
  • The Cardboard Collective
  • The Crunchy Chicken
  • The Good Human
  • The Green Mama blog
  • The Green Parent
  • The Healthy Home Economist
  • The Kitchn
  • The Lazy Homesteader
  • The Politics of Motherhood
  • The Radical Housewife
  • The Science of Mom
  • The Smart Mama
  • Twine
  • Upper Case Woman
  • Wandering Scientist
  • Words to Eat By
  • Working Moms Break

Eco-Stores Online

  • A Rainy Day Play
  • A Toy Garden
  • Alewives Fabrics
  • Apple Park
  • Armadillo Dreams
  • Art of Felting
  • Artterro
  • Ava Anderson
  • Baby Bazaar
  • Baby Bjorn
  • Baby Eco-trends
  • Baby, Don't Sweat It
  • Bella Luna Toys
  • Big Green Purse
  • Birchleaf Designs
  • Blue Fish Clothing
  • Blueberry Forest
  • Born at Home Toys
  • Brood Baby
  • Bubble and Bee
  • Camden Rose
  • Carolina Morning
  • Coastal Classic Creations
  • Down to Earth Toys
  • Earth Mama Angel Baby Organics
  • Ecovolvenow
  • Essential Safe Products
  • Fafu
  • FeeVertelaine
  • German Dolls
  • Global Goods Partners
  • Good things. Green things.
  • Goodnight Room NYC
  • Green Leaf Living
  • Green Planet Parties
  • Gypsy Forest
  • Handmaiden Canada
  • Hazelnut Kids
  • Holy Lamb Organics
  • Imagine Childhood
  • Island Picnic
  • Jupiter's Child
  • Kate Quinn Organics
  • Lafe's
  • Life without Plastic
  • LifeKind Bedding and Mattresses
  • Little Sapling Toys
  • Little Speckled Frog
  • Little Woodlanders
  • Lollibeans
  • Lucy and Mei Organic Clothing
  • Lusa Organics
  • Magic Cabin
  • Mama May I
  • Mama West Wind
  • Mammas 4 Earth
  • Mandy and Randy Toys
  • Meinl Nino Percussion
  • Miessence
  • Mighty Nest
  • Miyim toys
  • Modern Rust
  • Mommas Baby
  • Mona Luna
  • Mosey
  • Muddy Feet
  • My Little Green Shop (Canada)
  • Myriad Natural Crafts and Toys (UK)
  • Naturepedic
  • Nest Bedding
  • Nova Natural
  • Nubius Organics
  • Nurture My Body
  • Nushkie
  • Open Your Eyes Bedding
  • Organic and Healthy, Inc.
  • Organic Baby Garden
  • Organic Baby University
  • Ottobre Design
  • Palumba
  • Pebble
  • Planet box Lunchboxes
  • Pumpkin Doodle
  • Pure Play Kids
  • Rich Frog
  • Romp
  • Rosie Hippo Toys
  • Safe Kiddo
  • Sappho Cosmetics
  • Sarah's Silks
  • Savvy Rest
  • Sesame Seed Designs
  • Stockmar
  • Stubby Pencil Studio
  • Suki
  • Summer for Kids
  • Sunday in Color
  • Swift River Toys
  • Tegu
  • The Enchanted Cupboard
  • The Enchanted Forest
  • The Glass Baby Bottle
  • The Original Tree Swing
  • The Wooden Wagon
  • Tree blocks
  • Trees and Tots
  • Trends for Kids
  • Under the Nile
  • White Lotus
  • WIld Dill (toys and clothing)
  • Willodel
  • Woolies
  • Ziezo Designs

Products and Safety

  • Consumer Federation of America
  • Consumer Law & Policy
  • Consumer Reports
  • Environmental Health Trust
  • Good Guide
  • Public Citizen
  • Story of Stuff
  • The Consumerist
  • U.S. Public Interest Research Groups

Toxics and Food

  • Campaign for Safe Cosmetics
  • Center for Science in the Public Interest
  • Eat Wild
  • Environment America
  • Food and Water Watch
  • Food Politics
  • Food Safety News
  • Green Science Policy Institute
  • Healthy Child, Healthy World
  • Healthy Stuff
  • Mom's Rising Chemical Safety Blog
  • Natural Resources Defense Council
  • Organic Consumers Association
  • Pesticide Action Network
  • Safer Chemicals, Healthy Families
  • Skin Deep database
  • The Pump Handle
  • The Salt
  • Union of Concerned Scientists

Key words

  • babies
  • baby
  • Bisphenol-A
  • BPA
  • Business
  • California
  • chemicals
  • Chemical substance
  • Chicago Tribune
  • Child
  • children
  • cook
  • cooking
  • couch
  • craft
  • crafty
  • dinner
  • DIY
  • do-it-yourself
  • easy
  • eco-
  • environmental
  • environmental health
  • Facebook
  • Family
  • FDA
  • felt
  • Flame retardant
  • flame retardants
  • food
  • fun
  • furniture
  • green
  • health
  • healthy
  • Holiday
  • Home
  • humor
  • Ikea
  • infancy
  • Infant
  • infants
  • Infographic
  • lead
  • Maya
  • meal
  • mom
  • mommy blog
  • mother
  • New York Times
  • organic
  • Parent
  • parenting
  • parents
  • PBDEs
  • plastic
  • precautionary
  • PVC
  • recipe
  • recipes
  • recycle
  • safety
  • Shopping
  • simple
  • sofa
  • tips
  • toddler
  • Toxic
  • toxic chemicals
  • toxics
  • toys
  • tris
  • uncertainty
  • United States
  • upcycle

Photo credits

Many of the photographs of Maya used in the header were taken by my friend and extraordinary photographer, Jay Premack. You can see more of his work at www.jaypremack.com.
2012 election button related to green issues
Find out how bloggers feel the

Copyright

All rights reserved. 2012.
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
<span>%d</span> bloggers like this: